Seikōsui in the Honshiki Sanmondō

Introduction

The Honshiki sanmondō (本識三問答; “Three Dialogues on the Original Consciousness”)(Kimura Kyūho n.d.) is a martial-arts text bound after the Tengu geijutsuron (天狗芸術論) in the Bujutsu sōsho (武術叢書; Kokusho Kankōkai 国書刊行会, 1915; NDL 945805).(国書刊行会 (Kokusho Kankōkai, ed.) 1915)

Koma 7 is the 1915 editor’s kaidai (解題; bibliographic headnote), and it describes its authorship:1

Honshiki San-mondō (Three Questions and Answers on the Fundamental Principles) expounds the swordsmanship of the Yagyū school; according to Kenjutsu Fushiki-hen, the author was a senior disciple of Yagyū Muneyori. Unchū-ryū Ken Yōryō (Essentials of Unchū-ryū Swordsmanship) explains the swordsmanship of the Unchū school—which traces its lineage to the Yagyū school—and its author is the same person who wrote Kenjutsu Fushiki-hen. … 1. Kenjutsu Fushiki-hen (One Volume): This text is based on a manuscript in the collection of Mr. Jirōkichi Yamada. The author is Kimura Kyūho, who also expounded the Unchū-ryū swordsmanship mentioned above.

So the editor names Kimura Kyūho (木村久甫) as author of Fushiki-hen, and says Honshiki sanmondō’s author was a senior disciple of Yagyū Muneyori — sourcing that claim to Fushiki-hen itself. The Yagyū work that Fushiki-hen quotes is in this same volume. Hama no Manago (濱の眞砂; sand on a beach, figuring something vast) appears twice in part one of Honshiki sanmondō — “though swordsmanship is said to be the sand on a beach”2 (182) and “though the swords are various and many in number, like the sand on a beach”3 (183).

It opens with an encomium: “of the many swordsmanships in Japan, ancient and modern, it is by the devising of Yagyū Tajima-no-kami, of late years a resident of Yamato, that victory in swordsmanship has been made clear, and his is now the school without peer in the realm.”4 It then runs the whole gokui ladder — 三箇三見三調子, 丸橋, 手字手裏劔, 神妙劔, 水月, 迎捧心, and finally 西江水 with its waka — argues Yagyū-ryū against taryū (他流; the other schools) point by point (grip, shinai versus bokutō, drawing the opponent out), and repeatedly cites “in Tajima-no-kami’s judgment.”5 This is an unattributed insider text from Shinkage-ryū.

The 1915 editor prints a variant colophon that gives the provenance of the copy:6

Copied surreptitiously out of deep desire from Kinjō, marked “Yagyū-ryū colophon, to be kept private,” by Mitsuhashi Kanemitsu in Hōreki 8 (1758); then copied again, also surreptitiously, from the teacher Kimura Koreshige by Kawamura Yotake in Tenpō 1 (1830).

Kinjō is the standard byname for Nagoya. The work was twice ‘copied in secret’ (竊寫). If the Kinjō provenance holds, the Yagyū line here is the Owari faction, not Edo, which sits awkwardly with the repeated 但州 (Tajima province) attributions. This implies the text is from a practitioner or holding associated to the Owari line of the art and its inclusion of the seikōsui waka indicates that teaching was passed down in both major lines of the Yagyū family teaching (Owari and Edo) taught at that time.

Honshiki (本識; Skt. mūlavijñāna) is the Yogācāra “root consciousness,” a synonym of the ālayavijñāna. It expounds the method of Yagyū Munenori (柳生宗矩; styled Tajima-no-kami 但馬守) and treats seikōsui (西江水; “West River water”) as the highest gokui of the school — the culmination above the whole gokui series 手字・手裏劔・神妙劔・水月・迎捧心 (the source’s own ordering of the series varies). This makes it the fullest swordsmanship witness to the phrase whose Chan life is set out in the West River piece: here “swallow the West River water in one gulp”7 has become a sword gokui, complete with a waka that “swallows the river in one gulp.”

Below are passages that define and expound 西江水 (not the whole text, which also covers the 三心 dialogue, the 氣/理 discussion, and an archery analogy). Source readings follow the Bujutsu sōsho print; section headings are unique to this essay.

The Kimura Sukekurō Unchū-ryū

Kimura Tomoshige (木村友重), known by his tsūshō Kimura Sukekurō (木村助九郎), was a senior disciple of Yagyū Munenori who called his own teaching Unchū-ryū out of deference to his teacher’s school name, ceded the name to his fellow student Izubuchi Heibei (出淵平兵衛, also read Debuchi) of the Echizen Matsudaira house on being permitted to style his art Yagyū-ryū publicly, whereupon the name eventually reverted to the Yagyū house. (Wikipedia contributors 2026)

Hinatsu Shigetaka’s (日夏繁高) Honchō bugei shōden (本朝武藝小傳, 1716; “Short Biographies of Our Realm’s Martial Artists”) attests both men independently:

Kimura Sukekurō (木村助九郞) followed Tajima-no-kami Munenori and mastered the Shinkage-ryū (新陰流). Later he served Lord Yorinobu of Kishū (紀州賴宣卿), with a fief of 500 koku. When Munenori first taught swordsmanship to the shogun Iemitsu (大猷大君), Sukekurō served each time as his practice partner (o-aite 御合手).8

Izubuchi Heibei received Yagyū Munenori’s transmission and awakened to the essence of swordsmanship. Later he served Lord Tadamasa, the Echizen saishō (越前宰相忠昌卿), and made his name in sword and spear.9

Takahashi Shōichi’s conference abstract holds that Unchū-ryū comprises an Echizen line and a Yagyū line, separately constituted, both Yagyū Shinkage-ryū in content, with the Echizen line carried by Kimura Kyūho and the Yagyū line by Hirayama Kōzō through his teacher Yamada Mohei’s period of entry into Yagyū Shinkage-ryū. (Takahashi Shōichi 1999)

That does not sit easily with the Fushiki-hen’s own lineage recital, which gives Kyūho a Kaga spear school of Ōshū origin whose sword branch was founded by a man born in 1689. Both claimants are surnamed Kimura — Sukekurō Tomoshige of the Edo Yagyū orbit, and Kyūho of Kaga, some 130 years apart — and the collator’s variant-witness note (see below) adds a third man, Kimura Koreshige (木村是茂).

One of the three witnesses excerpts the first half of the appendix and carries two okugaki: a copy made from Kinjō (Nagoya),10 described as a Yagyū-ryū okugaki to be kept hidden, dated Hōreki 8/3 (1758), signed Mitsuhashi Kanemitsu; and a second copied from the house of Kimura Koreshige, Tenpō 1 winter (1830), signed Kawamura Yotake. The 1758 date precedes Kyūho’s own 1764 preface by six years, which either dates part of the material earlier than the appendix or indicates that what was excerpted is Yagyū rather than Kyūho material.

The text is classical prose — wabun with kanbun tags (千金莫傳, “not to be transmitted for a thousand in gold,” and the like) — not sōrōbun; embedded Chinese phrases are given readings where they occur.

Seikōsui

The Honshiki sanmondō expounds seikōsui as a swordsmanship culmination, explicitly Yagyū:

  • “Above this there is what is called seikōsui; it is the matter that lies beyond mastering all the studies of the mokuroku”11 — seikōsui as the teaching above the whole mokuroku;
  • “It is settled by seikōsui alone; all the studies, in the end, turn into willow”12 — all techniques reduce to seikōsui (the willow image; cf. Tsuki no Shō 良移心当和, Ryōi Shintō-ryū Yawara, kareki/yōryū (枯木/楊柳; dead wood and willow), p. 65);
  • “Lord Tajima, having attained the wheel of the myriad methods, out of the mind of ‘one gulp’ …”13 — attributes it to Yagyū Munenori (柳生但馬守) and glosses 一口 (the “one gulp” of 一口吸盡西江水);
  • “In my house there is a single wondrous and mysterious art of the sword; it is called seikōsui … it has nothing to do even with engaging, waiting and deception”;14 a waka headed “a verse on arriving at seikōsui”: “In swordsmanship there are the three — engaging, waiting, and deception — but gathered up and seen whole, they are just one”;15 and “the station of seikōsui, the principle of emptiness, is a thing with no form in its going and no path in its coming”16 (seikōsui as 空理, the principle of emptiness, and 天理, the principle of heaven).

This is an eighteenth-century witness that seikōsui functioned as the apex of Yagyū-Shinkage practice — tied to Munenori and the 一口 gloss — an independent line of the same kōan-in-swordsmanship tradition the Tsuki no Shō p. 71 invokes. It postdates Mitsuyoshi (so not a source for him) but corroborates that seikōsui was a live Shinkage culminating concept, not merely a Chan citation — strengthening the reading that p. 71 draws on a swordsmanship tradition, not only Mǎzǔ.

Above [all the rest] there is what is called seikōsui. It is the matter that lies beyond mastering the entire catalogue (mokuroku) of studies. Once seikōsui is transmitted, all those studies become useless — it is settled by seikōsui alone; all the studies, in the end, “turn into willow” (結句柳に成る). This is a place beyond ordinary reckoning. (…) In old times this study was also called mizume (見詰; “the fixed gaze”). (…) It is the making-round of everything there is and bringing it together — and this is seikōsui. Lord Tajima [Munenori], having attained the wheel of the myriad methods, named it out of the mind of “one gulp” (一口の心). This is the single sword-stroke of this school.17

The phrase “turns into willow”18 evokes the supple willow that yields and is never broken. Compare the kareki/yōryū pairing in the Ryōi Shintō-ryū Yawara section of the Tsuki no Shō (wa no koto 和之事, p. 65), whose “regard hardness as the father and softness as the mother”19 states the same supple-willow doctrine.

Ikku no shin (一口の心; “the mind of one gulp”) is the text’s own gloss on the 一口 of the Chan kōan 一口吸盡西江水 (“swallow the West River water in one gulp”), which is said to be the inspiration for the seikōsui name itself.

He then discusses seikōsui as mutō (無刀; no-sword):

The understanding of seikōsui is again of a different order. One does not [attend to] the enemy’s engaging-waiting-and-deception (ken-tai-hyōri); the enemy does not use blade, and I too use no blade — in the end both enemy and I are the principle of no-sword (mutō). For this reason Lord Tajima said, “I would have named it the No-Sword School (無刀流)” — at seikōsui this is exactly right. “Not to be transmitted for a thousand in gold; to be kept hidden,” and so on.20

Then the author discusses the teaching waka — “swallow the West River water in one gulp”:

In swordsmanship there are the three — engaging, waiting, and deception — but gathered up and seen whole, they are just one.
Casting off the manifold trainings of swordsmanship, swallow the West River water in one gulp.21

This is similar to the Tsuki no Shō content; the author then introduces the metaphor of the iron gate with three fearsome keepers:

“In my house there is a single eye of swordsmanship, named seikōsui. Even when one has finished the whole catalogue and reached geihōshin (迎捧心; unifying attack and defense), so long as one keeps engaging-waiting-deception in mind, it is [still merely] swordsmanship. Once one reaches seikōsui, to keep engaging-waiting-deception in mind is the mark of delusion.” (…) “Once seikōsui is transmitted, the iron gate of suigetsu is like a barrier-gate with its doors left unbarred” — so ran the transmission to his disciples of long standing. After that there was no iron gate; and those three fearsome gatekeepers called engaging, waiting, and deception — their tsukubō (突棒; push-poles) and sasumata (刺股; catch-forks) were no longer to be seen — so it is told.22

The gatekeepers’ implements are Edo arrest gear — the tsukubō and sasumata of the mitsudōgu (三つ道具; the three Edo implements for taking a criminal).

The author then discusses the ‘eye of the school’; the five things ‘not to abandon’; the tile-and-gate metaphor:

Seikōsui is the eye of Yagyū-ryū; there is nothing else besides. There are five things not to be abandoned in the mind: the mind’s underlying preparation [that is] seikōsui; moving quietly; the matter of “not-striking”; the matter of “not stopping the sword”; and not hurrying to win. Not to be transmitted for a thousand in gold. (…) The earlier studies are like a tile used to knock at a gate: by the tile’s merit one gets the gate opened, enters within, and finds the root-place of swordsmanship. But once the gate is broken through, the tile is of no use at all — now it is essential to throw the tile away. This, of course, is [only] after one has reached seikōsui.23

The tile-knocking-at-the-gate (敲門瓦子) phrase is common in Zen — the expedient discarded once it has served (cf. “the finger pointing at the moon”). Here the whole technical curriculum is that tile. Three further waka in the source press the same point (e.g. “if you bring out the studies-as-they-stand and try to strike seikōsui, you become [only] the striking-sword”24).

The uchitachi (打太刀) is the attacking, teaching role in paired kata — the shidachi/uchitachi contrast that structures the omitted sanmondō — so becoming the uchitachi means taking the teaching role, which loses in each kata.

Syncretic Gloss

Next we find the identification (西江水 = 空理 = 本來の面目 = 明德) of seikōsui with other capstone teachings:

“Seikōsui is the innermost teaching (gokui or hiden) of Yagyū-ryū, the rank of deepest and subtlest wonder. (…) Pondering it carefully: the myriad things begin from the one principle of the Great-Origin Emptiness (大元空の一理), and in the end return to the one principle. This principle is not existent, not non-existent; without color, without scent; and yet manifestly evident. This the Yagyū school names seikōsui and takes as its innermost meaning; my own Unchū-ryū (運籌流) calls it ken-yatō (劔矢當; ‘sword-arrow-hit’). In the Buddha-Dharma it is expounded as the immeasurable and inconceivable, or as ‘meeting one’s Original Face (本來の面目)’; in the Confucian way it is called ‘illustrious virtue (明德)’; in Shintō it is called ‘inner-and-outer purity (內外清淨).’ One who reaches this, Shintō reveres as a god (kami), the Buddha-way honors as a Buddha, the Confucian way esteems as a sage, and among ordinary people is prized as a ‘master’ (meijin). For all the myriad things, though name and form differ, the great origin from which they are wrought is in every case one principle only.”25

This is spoken by Kyūho (久甫) — Kimura Kyūho, author of the appendix (Unchūryū Kenjutsu Yōryō) and of the Kenjutsu fushiki-hen (劒術不識篇; “Swordsmanship: On Not Knowing”), though not of the Honshiki sanmondō proper — recounting a dream in which his own teacher glosses the Yagyū seikōsui by cross-tradition equivalences.

This is the clearest statement that seikōsui, on the sword side, was read as kūri (空理; the empty principle) — made equivalent to tenri (天理) — the same “one principle” the Chan, Confucian, and Shintō vocabularies each name differently.26

Previous studies are “cast off” but not annihilated:

At seikōsui, all the studies are cast off. Yet though cast off, they do not return to nothing. Up through shuji, shuriken, shinmyōken, geihōshin, there is a mind that clings to each rank, and a place one holds. At seikōsui one leaves the held-place, has no clinging mind, and — of itself — is [still] furnished with shuji, shuriken, shinmyōken, geihōshin, suigetsu and the rest; out of a midst where there is not a single thing, each matter answers of itself. This is what is meant by “casting off” those ranks. (…) “West River water” is a name for the west sea, broad and without limit. It seems to be called seikōsui by analogy to the empty principle’s being limitless, reaching upward even to the Tuṣita heaven and downward to the golden-wheel limit (金輪際; the nethermost base of the world). At this rank, it is not I who strike him — he comes and is struck.27

The etymological gloss of 西江水 with the boundless “west sea,” figuring the limitlessness of the kūri, is the text’s own reading of the phrase, independent of the Chan source.

The phrase “he comes and is struck”28 is developed in the source through the simile of a ruler’s edicts: the wrongdoer is not killed by the ruler but by his own crime.

Here, 手字 is read shuji, as in the Heihō Kadensho (兵法家伝書; “The Book of Family-Transmitted Military Arts”, 1632) compound 手字種利剣 (shuji shuriken); the catalogue’s shuji shuriken pair looks like that complex split into two entries.

On Emptiness and Heaven

The empty principle (空理) is precisely the heavenly principle (天理). The rank of the empty-principle seikōsui is a thing with no form in its going and no road in its coming. Yet the beginner must not take seikōsui to be merely “not one thing” and so fall wholly into a nihilistic view (無見). “No single thing in the mind” is not empty vacancy: the ki being firm, robust, and free-flowing is what is good.29

The caution against the “nihilistic view” (無見; a nihilistic misreading of emptiness) and the insistence on robust ki (氣剛健活達; “the ki being firm, robust, and free-flowing”) guard the seikōsui/kūri doctrine from being regarded as a vacant approach to swordsmanship.

Analysis

Willow, Storm and Settled Mist

In the Ryōi Shintō-ryū Yawara section of the Tsuki no Shō, the willow arrives with its contrast partner: “regard hardness as the father and softness as the mother”30 sets the hard and the pliant as complementary parents, and the kareki/yōryū pairing plays them out — under the ran (嵐; storm, also read arashi), the withered tree snaps where the willow bends and survives.

The Honshiki sanmondō keeps only the surviving term: at seikōsui the whole curriculum “turns into willow”31, with no withered tree in sight. Read against that section, the sword text’s image resolves naturally: what the studies lose at seikōsui is their kareki quality — fixity of form — and what persists is pliancy alone. The storm has its counterpart as well: keeping ken-tai-hyōri in mind is sound swordsmanship right up to geihōshin, and becomes mayoi no sō (迷の相; the appearance of confusion or delusion, a Buddhist term) only once seikōsui is reached — fixity that serves under ordinary pressure and fails at the last rank, as the withered branch fails in the wind.

The clause’s closing image, “the wind 〔having subsided?〕, like the mist that does not move” completes the sequence: storm, then stillness.32

The Honshiki sanmondō’s structural equivalent is the iron gate standing open with its three gatekeepers gone: once the end state is reached, the idea of testing simply vanishes. The unmoving mist also keeps company with a stillness that is not inertness (“it departs without form and arrives without a path”), consistent with that section’s insistence on robust ki.33

The remaining tail clauses sit in the same doctrinal register.

The “attained principles of earth, water, fire, and wind contained within”34 is the jūjutsu-side analogue of the reduction of many names to one principle (一理); and “even the wise is made foolish”35 echoes the ripened-wisdom motif of Takuan’s Fudōchi Shinmyōroku (不動智神妙録; see the companion translation), where matured wisdom withdraws inward and its bearer looks like one who knows nothing.

Since both texts stand in Munenori’s student orbit, the shared imagery is most economically read as common to Edo-Yagyū dōjō rather than borrowing in either direction; the link between Munenori and Fukuno Shichirōzaemon, founder of the Ryōi Shintō-ryū (see Initiative), as teacher and student is itself a traditional-account item; interested readers can consult Hinatsu’s Honchō bugei shōden and Watatani Kiyoshi and Yamada Tadashi’s Bugei ryūha daijiten (Watatani Kiyoshi (綿谷雪) and Yamada Tadashi (山田忠史) 1978).

On Yogācāra

Honshiki (本識; Skt. mūlavijñāna) refers to the Yogācāra “root consciousness”, a synonym of the ālayavijñāna. An exposition on Yogācāra by Takuan is also found in the Tsuki no Shō compiled by Yagyū Mitsuyoshi. Below, I describe that concept in brief and then relate the concept of trikāya (three bodies) to symbolism associated to breathing practices cultivated in the Jikishinkage-ryū lines of practice, which were influenced by this line of practice.

Yogācāra is an influential school of thought in Buddhist philosophy, also called Vijñānavāda or “the doctrine of consciousness”, dating from the early common era and attributed to Asaṅga (opens in a new tab) (310–390 CE; Skt. असंग; 無著; pinyin: Wúzhuó; romaji: Mujaku). Generally Buddhist schools assume six primary consciousnesses (Sanskrit: vijñāna, Tibetan: རྣམ་ཤེས་, Wylie: rnam-shes), the five physical consciousnesses of the senses and then the sixth consciousness associated to mental processes. Together they form the body-mind processes that are spoken to in the Heart Sūtra.

In Yogācāra, two additional forms or layers of consciousness (opens in a new tab) are described: kliṣṭamanovijñāna and ālayavijñāna, in order to explain the workings of karma. Asaṅga’s work titled the Mahāyānasaṃgraha (opens in a new tab) (攝大乘論; pinyin: Shè dàchéng lùn)36 survives in Chinese and Tibetan and consists of ten chapters, culminating in a discussion of Trikāya doctrine (opens in a new tab) (त्रिकाय, lit. “three bodies”; Chinese: 三身; pinyin: sānshēn; Japanese pronunciation: sanjin, Tibetan: སྐུ་གསུམ ) that examines the profound aspect of Buddhahood:

  • Dharmakāya (the Dharma body) associated with ultimate reality and all-pervading Buddha nature
  • Sambhogakāya (the Bliss body) associated with infinite forms and powers
  • Nirmāṇakāya (the manifestation body) associated with corporeal human form

This manifestation is non-dual: it is at the same time physical, the basis of the physical, and the underlying nature of reality. In Yogācāra this is called dharmadhātuviśuddhi (the purity of the dharma-realm): Buddhahood is described as abiding in neither saṃsāra nor nirvāṇa (saṃsāra-nirvāṇa-apratiṣṭhitatvāt).

Relation to A and Un

The A in Siddham script (bonji) found in Jikishinkage-ryū mokuroku symbolizes the formless Dharmakāya. Later Mahāyāna sutras, including the Lotus Sūtra, focus on a pairing of Dharmakāya with the form body, which I wonder if is then associated to the last character Un, forming the A-Un pairing used to describe the breathing (life giving) process of kokyū in the foundational practices of the Kashima-shinden Jikishinkage-ryū of swordsmanship.

End Notes

Contents: Mikkyō, Zen, and Daoist Sources in Shinkage-ryū · ← Owari Shinkage Yagyū-ryū · Unchū-ryū →

  1. 『本識三問答』は柳生流の劒法を說けるもの、說著者は柳生宗賴の高弟なる由『劒術不識篇』にあり。『運籌流劒要領』は柳生流を祖述したる運籌流の劒法を說けるもの、著者は『劒術不識篇』の著者なり。… 一、劒術不識篇一卷 本書は山田次郞吉氏所藏の寫本による。著者は前記運籌流の劒法を說ける木村久甫なり。 — Bujutsu sōsho, koma 7 (editor’s 解題). ↩

  2. 兵法は濱の眞砂とは言ひながら ↩

  3. 樣々太刀數多くして、濱の眞砂のごとしと雖 ↩

  4. 夫日本に古今劔術多しといへども、近代大和國住人柳生但馬守の工夫を以て、劔術に勝利を明らめ、今天下無雙の一流也 ↩

  5. 但馬守見立には ↩

  6. 從金城深望而竊寫之、柳生流之奧書可祕云々、寶曆八年三月 三橋兼光 此書者師家木村是茂先生より竊寫畢、天保元年冬十二月 河村世武 ↩

  7. 「一口吸盡西江水」 ↩

  8. 木村助九郞者從但馬守宗矩達新陰流、後仕紀州賴宣卿領采邑五百石、始宗矩奉授刀術於大猷大君之時、助九郞每度奉候於御合手 ↩

  9. 出淵平兵衞者得柳生宗矩之傳、悟刀術之妙旨、後仕越前宰相忠昌卿、顯其名於刀槍 ↩

  10. 從金城 ↩

  11. 「此上に西江水と云事有り、目録悉くの習ひを極めて其上の儀也」 ↩

  12. 「西江水一つにて濟む事也、悉くの習ひは結句柳に成る」 ↩

  13. 「但馬守萬法の輪を得德して一口の心を以て…」 ↩

  14. 「家に唯一つ奇妙不思議の劔術有り、是を西江水と號す…懸待表裏にも…かゝはらず」 ↩

  15. 西江水に至りての歌: 「兵法は懸待表裏みつなれど、つゞめて見れば、たゞひとつなり」 ↩

  16. 「空理西江水の位は、行くに形なく來るに路なき物なり」 ↩

  17. 此上に西江水と云事有り、目錄悉くの習ひを極めて其上の儀也。西江水を傳受すれば右悉くの習皆役にたたず、西江水一つにて濟む事也。悉くの習ひは結句柳に成るといへり。是は凡慮の及びがたき所也。(…)此習ひを昔は見詰とも言へり。(…)有程の事を悉く丸くして合する儀也、こゝを以て西江水也。但馬守萬法の輪を得德して一口の心を以て名付得るとなり。此流の一振太刀是也。 ↩

  18. 結句柳に成る ↩

  19. 剛を父とし弱を母とす ↩

  20. 西江水の心得は又格別也。敵の懸待表裏を知らず、敵劔戟をつかはず、我又劔戟をつかはず、我も敵も畢竟無刀の道理也。是に依て但馬守も無刀流と名付けんものをといひ給へり。西江水に至ては尤の儀也。千金莫傳可祕云々。 ↩

  21. 西江水に至りての歌: 「兵法は懸待表裏みつなれど、つゞめて見れば、たゞひとつなり」 「兵法の數の習を打ちすてゝ、西江水を一口に呑む」 ↩

  22. 我家に一つの劔術の眼有り、西江水と號す。目錄の習悉く濟みて捧心迄至るといふとも、懸待表裏を心にかくる劔術也。西江水に至りての上は、懸待表裏を心にかくる事は迷の相也。(…)西江水を傳授の上は、水月の鐵門は關の戶さゝぬ風情なりと言ひて、舊弟子に傳授有りけり。其後は鐵門もなし。尤懸待表裏といふおそろしき三人の門番、突棒さすまたも見えざりけりとかや。 ↩

  23. 西江水は柳生流の眼也。此外別にあらず。心に捨てざる事五つあり。心の下作り西江水、靜に步む事、あたらぬと云事、太刀を打とめぬといふこと、勝を急がざる事是也。千金莫傳。(…)前の習事は門をたたく瓦の如し。其瓦の德にて門を開くべきことを得て內に入り、兵法の根本の所を見付けたり。扨門を破りて後は、瓦は少しも役にたゝず、今は瓦を捨ること肝要なり。尤も是は西江水に至りたる上のこと也。 ↩

  24. 「有體の習をいだし西江水を打たんとすれば 打太刀になる」 ↩

  25. 西江水といふ事、柳生流の奧義、最深微妙の位なり。(…)つら〳〵あんずるに、萬物は大元空の一理より始り、又終に一理に歸す。此理といふもの、有にあらず無にあらず、色もなく香もなし、しかも又顯然たり。是を柳生流にて西江水と名付けて奥意とす。予が運籌流にては劔矢當と號す。佛法にとくは無量不可思議といひ、また本來の面目に逢ふなどと云。儒道にては明德と號す。神道にては內外清淨と云と見えたり。是に至りたるを、神道にては神とあがめ、佛道にては佛と敬ひ、儒道にては聖人と貴ぶ、凡人の中にては名人と賞翫すと云。一切萬物、名と形は異なるといへども、其成す所の大元は皆悉く一理のみと見るべし。 ↩

  26. The equation to 明德 is the Daxue; 本來の面目 is Chan. ↩

  27. 西江水に至りては悉くの習ひ捨る儀なり。又捨るといへども、無に歸るにはあらず。手字、手裏劔、神妙劔、迎捧心などまでは、其位々々に着する心あり、又持つ所あり。西江水に至りては持所をはなれ、着する心もなく、自然に手字、手裏劔、神妙劔、迎捧心、水月等を具足し、一物なき中より、夫々の事自然に應ず。是をさして右の位を捨るといふ。(…)西江水とは西の海の廣く限りなき名なり。空理の限りなく、都卒天・金輪際迄も行渡りて有るといふ事をなぞらへて、西江水といふと見えたり。此位に至りては、我より彼れを打つにあらず、彼來て打たるゝなり。 ↩

  28. 彼來て打たるゝ ↩

  29. 空理といふは則ち天理の事なり。空理西江水の位は、行くに形なく來るに路なき物なり。然れども初心の人、西江水を唯無一物なりと計り心得て、すべて無見に堕すべからず。心頭無一物とて、空虛の事にあらず、氣は剛健活達なる事を善とす。 ↩

  30. 剛を父とし弱を母とす ↩

  31. 結句柳に成る ↩

  32. 「風は〔をさまりて?〕霞の動かざるが如し」 ↩

  33. 行くに形なく來るに路なき ↩

  34. 土水火風の得理此中に籠もる ↩

  35. 賢きも愚となす ↩

  36. Shè dàchéng lùn běn 攝大乘論本 (Asaṅga, trans. Xuánzàng 玄奘), Bǐ guǒ zhì fēn 彼果智分 (the trikāya chapter) — CBETA T1594 (T31n1594): 「三種佛身:一、自性身,二、受用身,三、變化身」 (sān zhǒng fó shēn: yī zìxìng shēn, èr shòuyòng shēn, sān biànhuà shēn). Paramārtha’s earlier recension is Shè dàchéng lùn 攝大乘論 T1593. ↩