Introduction

Daoist Internal Alchemy in Early Kenjutsu

Kashima Shinden Jikishinkage-ryū (鹿島神傳直心影流) – Jikishinkage-ryū in brief – is one of the strongest surviving forms of medieval Japanese kenjutsu (剣術; swordsmanship). One should ask why – and this work is an effort to provide an answer to that question.1

Key in that discourse will be an examination of its overall organization, structure of teachings, and what philosophical and religious concepts are used to describe its innermost organizing principles. To do so, we must examine first the influence religion and philosophy has had on Japanese martial culture, especially in terms of Zen, esoteric Buddhism, Daoism, and Shamanism.

When looking at Chinese influences on Japanese martial arts in particular, there are two primary time periods of relevance: pre or early Tokugawa influences and post Meiji influences. First, in the late 16th and early 17th centuries, travel between China and Japan led to historical examples of Chinese influence on Japanese martial arts, beyond the general import of philosophy and culture from China to Japan. One example is the possible teaching of Chén Yuánbīn (陳元贇 often glossed as Chin Genpin), which led to the genesis or modification of several forms of koryū jūjutsu (古流 柔術; older methods of grappling dating prior to 1868). (Amdur 2018; Hummel 2017)

Another is the transit of swordsmen between Japan and China. Liu Yunfeng (劉雲峰) studied Japanese sword methods and taught them to Cheng Zongyou (程宗猷), who then published a treatise on the long saber as part of his famous compilation Gēng Yú Shèngjì (耕餘剩技). Later, a pilgrimage is made to China by the master swordsman Ogasawara Genshinsai Minamoto no Nagaharu (小笠原源信斎源長治, 1574–1644), student of Shinkage hyōhō, who is reputed to have both taught martial method and been exposed to contemporary Chinese teachings. Upon his return to Japan, he founded the Shin (True) Shinkage hyōhō, which later evolved into what today is called Jikishinkage-ryū. (Karukome Yoshitaka 2020)

The so-called internal martial arts of Tàijíquán and Xíngyìquán likely date from the late 16th or early 17th century. Bāguàzhǎng is of more recent vintage, being developed in the mid 19th century. The three share common characteristics that seem to be compatible and different from older martial arts that also provide a mechanism for reaching high levels of personal development. Due to their Daoist (older spelling: Taoist; pinyin is used throughout this volume) influence, they can be contrasted from the older Chán (禪 traditional Chinese, 禅 modern kanji; pronounced Zen in Japanese) Buddhist influenced external martial arts (which need not be a pejorative term).

Both these famous examples in Japan date from very early in the development of the nèijiā that survive today. There are, from my perspective, echoes of Xíngyìquán found in Jikishinkage-ryū postures, movements, organization, and cutting actions.

This caused me, as I learned more of both arts’ compositions, to consider what it would mean to take these echoes seriously and pull the thread on what the influence of Daoist practices were on this branch of Shinkage-ryū, especially in its early, formative years.

As we will see, the core principles of Jikishinkage-ryū arranged in two sections of the mokuroku. Essential teachings are called katsu (克; victory) in older mokuroku and koto (事; matter or topic) in later mokuroku. Gokui (極意; inner secrets) are the core philosophical principles of the art. These sections of the mokuroku include extensive use of both Buddhist and Daoist concepts.

In contemporary writings on Jikishinkage-ryū, Rinzai Zen influence is emphasized, especially due to the popularization of Hōjō in the west by the late Ōmori Sōgen (大森 曹玄, 1904–1994). I hope this work will do a small measure to restore the balance of analysis to call attention to and recognize the Daoist and esoteric Buddhist influences on Shinkage-ryū.

Towards the end of this work, we will turn to an examination of portions of the older curriculum of Shinkage-ryū and Aisu Kage-ryū that was likely maintained in the first six generations of Jikishinkage-ryū practice.

Sources, Conventions, and Methods

The bulk of the analysis in this work is based on an examination of 20^th^ century books by Yamada, Ishigaki, and Saito, as well as source documents they reproduce, and holdings of Waseda University, including:

  1. Yoshida Katsunori 吉田克礼. Jikishin-kageryū heihō mokuroku shidai 直心影流兵法目録次第. Autograph manuscript scroll, Meiwa 5 (1768). 18.1 × 319.3 cm. Addressed to Isaki Masaki 井嵜政記; with verso endorsements transferring transmission from Shimizu Kiyoyuki 志水清行 to Isaki Kotōta 井崎小藤太, and from Yoshida Katsutada 吉田克忠 to Isaki Minato 井崎湊 dated Tenpō 14 (1843); seals: 克礼, 清行, 克忠. Call no. ケ05 01032 0001. Waseda University Library Kotenseki Sōgō Database, Tokyo.
  2. Yoshida Katsunori 吉田克礼. Jikishin-kageryū heihō mokuroku soejō 直心影流兵法目録添状 [letter of conveyance accompanying the mokuroku]. Autograph manuscript scroll, Meiwa 5 (1768). 18.1 × 171.8 cm. Addressed to Isaki Masaki 井嵜政記; seal: 克礼. Call no. ケ05 01032 0002. Waseda University Library Kotenseki Sōgō Database, Tokyo.
  3. Naganuma Shōbe-e 長沼庄兵衛 (transmitter); Ogawa Yashichi 小川弥七 (copyist). [Jikishin-kageryū heihō] Hōjō [直心影流兵法]法定. Manuscript scroll, Kansei 12 (1800). 18.1 × 840.0 cm; ink annotations; insect damage; scroll mounting; includes catalog of contents (目録之次第). Call no. ケ05 01032 0003. Waseda University Library Kotenseki Sōgō Database, Tokyo.

Machine Translation and other language models were used to provide kanji identification, translation, and discovery of related material available online, as well as to proofread the resulting commentary, normalize romanization, etc. Credit is thus due to Google Gemini Pro and Claude Opus 4.6-4.8 language models.

For Chinese words, pinyin transliteration is used consistently along with Japanese transliteration, even when source material provides content in other conventions such as Wade-Giles.

Romanization is provided italicized on the first occurrence of a word, along with its source characters and definition, and then words are used normally thereafter.

Origin Myths

We know that today Jikishinkage-ryū looks very different from other lines of Shinkage-ryū. It is likely that the period Ogasawara is said to have spent in China caused the resulting differences. Jikishinkage-ryū is well known for its focus on breathing, posture and power and its relative scarcity of explicit tactics compared to other lines of Shinkage-ryū.

Aside from questions regarding specific influence, either of martial theory or practice from China to Japan, if we look besides general anatomy and pre-modern types of movement (from hunting, agriculture, horsemanship, archery, spear, etc.) it seems, at least at the beginning of the Edo period, there is an opportunity for there to be some common ground in place that could follow similar, albeit culturally specific, developments in both cultures.

This would only be made easier if there was movement of skilled persons between the countries (as in the case of Chén Yuánbīn and Ogasawara). Daoist teachings were already long present in Japan, along with Buddhist and Confucian teachings imported from China, so it is not outside the realm f possibility that some arts might develop from similar conceptual frameworks.2

If we assume Chinese internal martial arts developed around the same time as Ogasawara’s travels, some Japanese martial artists in the Edo period likely did possess the necessary philosophical framework of Daoism needed to discover or develop somewhat analogous internal martial arts ideas.

The Chinese methods introduced to Japan during the early Edo period, even if they involve body development, breath practice, sensitivity and balance, are most likely a mixture of Shàolín (少林) practices, proto-internal martial arts concepts, and practices derived from important Daoist Qìgōng (氣功; life-force skill or accomplishment) practices such as the Bāduànjǐn (八段錦; Eight Sections of Brocade) and Yìjīn Jīng (易筋經; Muscle-Tendon Change), which is a series of dǎo yǐn (導引; “guiding and leading”) exercises that likely existed in the early 17^th^ century and is associated with the Shàolín lineage but draws on older Daoist body-conditioning practices. Methods of iron shirt or iron palm training are also quite sophisticated and can lead to the ability of a martial arts practitioner to express great levels of power and rooted stability. It may be some of these methods are what Chén Yuánbīn provided – the history remains unclear.3

Discourse about internal power is complicated by the fact that the style of Tàijíquán practiced in Chen Village, includes a powerful set of routines called pào chuí (炮捶; “cannon fist”), which is famous for its expressions of short range explosive power. The expressions of stability and power generation at short distances demonstrated by these advanced practitioners have been of great recent interest to some members of the classical Japanese martial arts community, but this does not mean they influenced jūjutsu or kenjutsu historically.

Post Tokugawa, due to Japanese designs on expansion in the modern era, there was more exposure of Japanese budō practitioners to Chinese martial arts.

However, lineal relationships are rare due to the hostile relationship between the two countries during that time. While some did travel to Manchuria as part of Japanese Imperial occupation in the late 19^th^ and early 20^th^ centuries, it is unlikely that most would have been able to receive instruction from high-level martial arts teachers during their travels.4

It is important to recognize that the dialectic of hard versus soft does not need to be equated with the dialectic of internal versus external or what concepts such as aiki mean, as compared to other forms of Japanese jūjutsu. For example, Xíngyìquán is a very hard style of martial arts, but is considered nèijiā. Tàijíquán has several different variants, each with their own thoughts on how to specialize or organize their practice. Yang, Wu, Chen and Sun style practitioners might even not agree among themselves, when asked, on what proper Tàijí practice is.

The above discussion touches a bit on what internal martial arts are, at least in China, and how they might relate to some Japanese martial arts. But then, a natural subsequent question might be: what is internal power itself and how does it relate to Japanese martial arts? This begs further questions:

  1. Is there only one kind of internal power?

  2. What types of internal power can be cultivated?

  3. Are they all equally relevant to a specific art?

  4. In applying them, are you integrating internal power in an optimal manner?

  5. In doing so, is one’s approach still what it started out as?

For example, if a person studies Jikishinkage-ryū and masters kodachi and then adapts it to close-range armed grappling, when they then perform something that looks like shomen uchi ikkyo (an upper-level downward arm bar) from Aikidō, is it Aikidō or something fundamentally different?

Some additional questions include whether given the benefits of internal power and stability, is it important to seek each art’s specific methodologies or can alternatives suffice? Is it important to be able to do what our teachers did, how they did it, or just be able to do what they did?

In the case of Jikishinkage-ryū, we are fortunate, because the inner essence of the art contains teachings and concepts drawn from Daoism (likely of the Complete Reality School) and both the Zen and esoteric schools of Buddhism. We can examine and contextualize its practice from those perspectives.

At the same time, it is important to recognize that there can sometimes be a distinction between what one’s mental framework is for their practice and what they are actually doing, especially for autodidacts. Many ideas get lost in translation and martial arts are an example rather than an exception.

Sasamori Takemi of Ono-ha Ittō-ryū speaks of using his dāntián (丹田; center, Japanese tanden) quite clearly in talking about kenjutsu and kiri-otoshi, which is supposed to drop an opponent where they stand. Jikishinkage-ryū uses the same name for its downward cut, though, as we will see, its densho gives its own kiri-otoshi an inner meaning, the reiken (霊劔; spirit sword), that is not the Ittō-ryū technique. Sasamori also references Ittō-ryū taijutsu explicitly, which provides additional support to Ellis Amdur’s thesis that more modern arts such as Aikidō and Daitō-ryū are related to Ittō-ryū teachings from Takeda’s family, and the internal power taken from that source, rather than Takeda Sokaku’s later training in Jikishinkage-ryū. Takeda was also an avid practitioner of Shingon Mikkyō (密教; esoteric Buddhism). (Amdur 2018; Sasamori Takemi and Hague 2016)

What the above does not answer is why all Edo period Japanese jūjutsu did not similarly develop concepts of internal power or reputations for extreme power in their training such as what is found in the art this work is about.

Kenjutsu similarly. Only Jikishinkage-ryū, which had a clearly documented influence from Chinese martial arts and philosophy, seems to put power development at such priority in its training.

We will see below that Jikishinkage-ryū teachings, including their inner-most portions, provide ample evidence for the permeation of Daoist methods of approaching swordsmanship, along with concepts drawn from both Zen (as is commonly expected when discussing this art) and esoteric (so-called lightning vehicle or Vajrayāna) schools of Buddhism. Early tutelary deities are drawn from Vajrayāna and teachings reference both Chinese military classics and reference terminology that is clearly esoteric in origin. This was common among early ryūha.

More uniquely, the physical practice of Jikishinkage-ryū embodies principles of body organization and movement (careful stepping with clearly delineated weight distribution, erect posture with a bow of the back and arch through the hips and pelvis, soft so-called ‘reverse’ breathing methods, an emphasis on perception and sensitivity, the ability to generate immense levels of power) – all hallmarks of internal martial arts training.

The description above may describe an ideal case, and arts often fail to live up their ideals. The answer to the question of the extent of adoption of Daoist methods of cultivation in kobudō may depend on what a person is trying to achieve.

This is the motivation behind the question of whether it is sufficient to be able to do what a specific teacher or teachers once did, some of what they did and by the same means. There is also the question of what a decision procedure is in this day, outside of a kata pedagogy and the gokui organizing methodology, for evaluating levels of skill in a practitioner.

One can quote philosophy all day, but in Tàijíquán (as a concrete example) there is the concept of direct push hands practice to evaluate levels of relative skill between practitioners (although that itself can devolve and become devoid of meaning in the wrong context) and a set of classics that one can consult to evaluate whether one is still doing Tàijíquán. The first is a question of being good or not good (relative level of skill), whereas the latter is a question of doing Tàijí or not doing Tàijí.

Even with textual resources available, there is extreme variation in the outward form of different Tàijí styles and arguments about correctness and effectiveness across major groups and differing accounts of Tàijí history.

In the history and anthropology of Chinese martial arts, the perspective of arts being “internal” as opposed to “external” likely was developed in the 19th century, when instructors of Tàijíquán, Bāguàzhǎng, and Xíngyìquán decided that their arts shared similar underlying ideas and organizing principles, even though outwardly they appeared different.

They also wanted to distinguish themselves from the Shàolín schools of martial arts, whom they felt were organized differently at a foundational level, and as Zen Buddhist-influenced, somewhat foreign, their philosophy having being imported from India (albeit refined into the Chán school once in China) rather than purely indigenous to China, as Daoism is. They referred to their arts as nèijiā (internal) and the Shàolín derived arts as waijiā (external). The nèijiā are not as old as waijiā — precisely because they are a reaction to the existing high-level practices prevalent during their time, as opposed being the culmination or epitome of them.

The term waijiā should, however, not be taken as being pejorative. The subject of what is internal versus what is external is a complex one, but it is always a mistake to conflate the dialectic of good vs. bad with internal vs. external in discussions of martial arts. Indeed, there are skilled and mediocre practitioners of nèijiā and waijiā both.

In general, however, one can think of internal training as developing a different or non-intuitive reaction or reflex or quality in a specific domain (e.g., strength, speed, balance) whereas external training is concerned with taking the normative expression of a quality and developing it to its logical conclusion. For example, developing the speed of a punch or kick is an external skill, whereas developing relaxation and sensitivity so that one’s own punch is quicker than an opponent’s, no matter what their speeds are in of itself, would be an internal skill. There is generally, in internal training, a focus on inner awareness and awareness in relation to the world that a skill is measured within (e.g., how hard can a person punch a moving, reacting, opponent, and what effect does that punch have on him) rather than only its effect in of itself (e.g., how hard one can punch a stationary object).

Often in Tàijíquán practice we are reminded that besting someone is not enough. If the method by which an opponent is defeated does not respect Tàijí principles, the result is not a proper expression of Tàijíquán, even if we can push the other person off balance.

One common refrain seen in martial arts practitioners interested in internal martial arts is a quest for greater amounts of power — psycho-spiritual willpower or strength of personality but also the more prosaic ability to move fast, be strong, and resist damage and pain. Maybe a place to begin in discussing this general topic is to consider what working definitions of strength, energy, and power are.

We notice energy not always by feeling it directly, but often visually by watching its effect and inferring its source. Often, that inference is mistaken. For example, we see someone throw someone, and when there is a big movement resulting, we instinctively believe there was a great amount of power exhibited by the thrower. Wanting to be able to do the same, we might try to get stronger by lifting weights or working on our technique. However, some displays of skill are so profound we begin to wonder if, in a superstitious way, there is not something more involved.

The ideas of Qì (氣; life-force) and prāṇa (प्राण; life-force) figure importantly as an organizing metaphor in Daoist and Buddhist ideas of health, healing, transformation and self-realization respectively. When we practice breath work, we develop certain internal sensations of what we perceive as energy moving through our bodies.

If we assume that energy can manifest itself external to our selves – rather than just being our own physical sensations of cultivating circulation of the blood, enervation of the nerves, and pressure and stretching and conditioning of the body – we will direct our focus and intention outward instead of developing an inner awareness of force and structure. We need to develop an ability to listen to our bodies so we may improve our ability to experience those sensations. In doing so, we can make our body more and more integrated and connected. We are then able to exhibit more efficient posture, relaxed movement, and skillful absorption and discharge of force. But that force is entirely physical – the product of an increased integration of body and mind.

The required method of development in this area is quite foreign to many martial artists. It involves an inner awareness and slow and steady training of the body to perceive the forces acting on it. One hopes to gain the ability to convey forces through the body’s structure in a very efficient manner.

To do so, we must also refine and improve this structure. This is far from blind extension or contraction of a single muscle or muscle group. It is also far from simply coordinated movement of the body, although a great deal of coordination is required. Merely recruiting more joints and muscles into a movement does not allow one to reproduce the higher levels of internal skill in martial arts. That is the start, not the finish. Rather, we need to replace our original instincts about how we stabilize the body, how we respond to, and how we generate force. A great deal of the effort involved is dealing with the nervous system – how the reflexes of the body work when the body is enervated and when relaxed.

At first, when we engage in breathing practice and do a moving meditation, we cultivate sensations in our bodies and can make our martial arts practice feel much more vibrant and alive. But without knowledge of how to apply the force of the ground through our bodies in a relaxed manner – the simple normal force in response to a push against a fixed structure like the ground in the sense of static analysis – we can feel innervated or aroused by our breathing or Qìgōng all we like, but it will do us little benefit in a martial encounter. In essence, if we do not know the path we are attempting to walk, and are not being properly guided, we can delude ourselves into thinking that we are more “powerful” because of our breathing or stance-training or meditative practice, but we cannot put that “power” to use. Not knowing any better, some people rationalize these internal sensations as a presence external to their own body. They then don’t have a mechanism by which to apply the little sensation they do feel in a constructive manner.

There can be energy, stress, or strain within the body as well as potential energy from the weight of the body. There is also the normal force of the ground acting back on the body’s structure or form. Force issued or momentum imparted in an opponent, when a product of these three ideas, can be said to be “internal”. Proper application of internal force is not felt by the issuer – it is transmitted completely into the target of a push or strike. Any force felt by the issuer is force that was not conveyed along a pure path into the other person – inefficiencies in direction or guidance caused, like friction, the force to act on ourselves instead of the other person.

The most profound applications of correct technique do not allow the receiver to discern anything about them. The forces involved can be an order of magnitude more powerful than what one would imagine is ordinarily possible. This points not to some other-worldly development, but rather to an integrated use of the body in a very specific and refined manner.

In that nèijiā such as Bāguàzhǎng, Xíngyìquán, Tàijíquán develop the body in specific ways, and thus the body’s ability to manifest Qì, they are said to be a form of Qìgōng. Conversely, some forms of Qìgōng are actually standing martial arts practices in disguise – Yìquán is a good example, as well as people who practice Tàijíquán exclusively for health. So, Qìgōng and nèijiā are related. There are also Daoist religious practices, called Dàogōng or Nèigōng, which are physical-spiritual efforts to transform the body into an immortal state. Qìgōng is a fundamental part of these practices as well, but their methods are extensive, and constitute a path into themselves. One that is leveraged by internal martial arts, to be certain.

Body development in of itself is not necessarily external or internal – one may develop skill at Tàijíquán or Bāguàzhǎng, but when a person strikes someone, the result will depend on their body – its development, and organization – irrespective of the art whose tactic they used to do so.

Body development methods drawn from various Qìgōng have their place in both internal and external martial arts. However, training methodologies and intent may differ between the two.

Regardless of training methodology, levels of body development and organization provide some of the key discriminators between high-level and low-level skill, irrespective of style.

Historically in China, many civilian or monastic martial traditions stem from Shàolín Temple, a Chán (禪; major school of Mahayana Buddhism, called Zen in Japan) temple that was the seat of the legendary patriarch Bodhidharma (菩提達磨; Pútídámó or Bodai Daruma). Later, we see Daoist martial arts develop from the broader context of Chinese martial arts, claiming association with monasteries and sacred mountains such as Wǔdāng Shān (武當山).

Jikishinkage-ryū contains both Daoist and Buddhist teachings in its core essence and may best be regarded as a mixture of internal and external approaches to martial practice, similar to how the arts of Bājíquán and Tōngbèiquán are today regarded. It is however likely the case that in the 19th and 20th centuries, excessive practice of hard breathing and cultivation of intense training using hundreds of executions of Hōjō as a training mechanism by Jikishinkage-ryū adepts may have caused some to lose a portion of these principles in a quest for intense self-actualization through overly extreme training.

Unless that 19th century practice was more relaxed and smooth than is typically found today. By the end of this work, we invite the reader to consider that question and its possible ramifications if answered in the affirmative.

Regardless of methodology, or outcome, different levels of body development and organization provide some of the key discriminators between high-level and low-level skill, irrespective of a particular style.

An open question remains, namely whether there is one correct or optimal form of body development that once informed many styles of martial arts and is now largely lost in many circles of practice.

The author is of the opinion and open to correction on this point, that development must be defined with respect to a goal – strength should be developed to be sufficient for accomplishing a component of a result (e.g., throwing someone, hitting someone, cutting someone), but simply possessing great strength alone does not remove the necessity for proper strategy and tactics.

To amplify that statement, while body development, especially the kind advocated by the internal martial arts, can be of great benefit to a practitioner, it alone does not complete a curriculum of study. It has to express itself through martial practice. An open question that should be examined (in another essay, perhaps) is what the differences are in Qìgōng between internal and external styles of practice and how that develops the quality of force (sometimes called jin) they then express in their practice.

Broader Context of Transitional Arts

In the section on small sword (kodachi) practice, we will provide interpretations of kata that involve close-range armed grappling called kogusoku. Jikishinkage-ryū was said to at one point contain methods of grappling, which were lost over time, as schools specialized during the Edo period.

To help inform that later discussion, we provide some context that helps contrast modern with classical approaches to martial arts. We do so with a focus on grappling, as that is a more accessible topic to most readers than kenjutsu, given the popularity of Jūdō, Aikidō (even if waning), Brazilian jiujitsu and Mixed Martial Arts in the 21st century.

We hope to largely avoid discussions of sword arts in comparison to one another, except as restricted to surviving lineages of Shinkage-ryū and how they technically relate, as these are living entities that continue to evolve. A practice that is in decline might be revived, and a practice that seems strong today might decline in the future.

Since Jikishinkage-ryū is itself a transitional art, having gone through an expansive phase at the end of the Edo period, aligning itself in some lines as an adjunct to the development of the fencing sport of kendō, and then contracting back to a smaller size, the parallels are worth considering.

Japanese grappling styles varied in the organization of their technical content. Some examples of classical (pre Meiji-era) arts include:

  • Tenjin Shin’yō-ryū jūjutsu has 124 kata divided in several sections including themes of idori (kneeling), tachi-ai (standing) and koppō (resuscitation).

  • Kitō-ryū (起倒流) jūjutsu taught 30 kata, 21 of which are preserved in jūdō’s Koshiki no Kata.

  • Totsuka-ha Yōshin-ryū is said to have preserved 303 kata in four sections (shoden, chuden, jōden, kaiden) passed down from older styles of Yōshin-ryū.

  • Sōsuishi-ryū preserves a curriculum of kumi-uchi organized into 48 kata. Its weapons curriculum called koshi no mawari adds to this.

  • Katori Shintō-ryū, albeit a weapons-focused tradition, has a section of 36 yawara kata in its curriculum that are rarely demonstrated.

  • In contrast to those smaller traditions, the Bitchū-den (備中伝) of Takenouchi-ryū has accumulated hundreds of kata in its curriculum over almost five hundred years.

The list goes on.

In most of these variants of yawara (柔; grappling) practice, kata is utilized in a classical manner, with a focus on zanshin (awareness) and combative mindset, with the teacher acting as the opponent in order to be able to gauge the student’s effectiveness and draw out their skill over time.

Transitional or what might be called neoclassical arts typically reverse that role, either having the teacher in the demonstrating role (almost as a form of performance art, especially in arts with complicated many-step techniques or intricate submission holds) or abandon that dichotomy to focus on sport:

  • Daitō-ryū Aiki-jūjutsu, a Meiji-era form of yawara (held to be older by its practitioners), contains 118 ‘basic’ jūjutsu techniques and then adds 53 aiki no jutsu kata, 36 advanced or hiden techniques, and a self-defense curriculum of 84 waza. Later additions to its curriculum include menkyo-kaiden kata.

  • Daitō-ryū Takumakai maintains a curriculum of around 500 techniques recorded in their sōden record of teachings of two of its early teachers, Ueshiba Morihei and Takeda Sokaku.

  • Modern sumo, albeit ritualized grappling, has traditionally 48 basic techniques and today 82 possible winning techniques.

  • Kōdōkan Jūdō, albeit a form of sport in the modern era, has 100 techniques encompassing throwing and grappling that are synthesized from Tenjin Shin’yō-ryū, Kitō-ryū and other sources.

Some of the above grappling styles have a limited curriculum, while others that include a variety of weapons practices (such as the different lines of Yōshin-ryū, Yagyū Shingan-ryū and Takenouchi-ryū) possess a much larger set of teachings.

Others, such as Sōsuishi-ryū teach grappling, iai and kenjutsu utilizing a smaller number of teachings. This is similar to fierce arts such as Jikishinkage-ryū that maintain a more compact curriculum to great effect.

In the case of Japanese jūjutsu, many traditions died out as Japan modernized and Kōdōkan jūdō became a standard part of the Japanese educational system. Many jūjutsu dōjō wound up teaching a standard jūdō curriculum alongside their older kata.

Interest in grappling and throwing was not limited to Japan, although those are possibly the best known examples in the west. In China, qínná (擒拿; methods of seizing joints) is an important part of many martial traditions including Fujian White Crane, Northern Eagle Claw and Tiger Claw. Eagle Claw, as but one example, contains a set of 108 qínná teachings.

In addition, internal martial arts styles such as Bāguàzhǎng, Tàijíquán and Xíngyìquán incorporate various grappling and throwing methods into their curricula. Some 20th century Tàijíquán masters, including Chén Fākē (陳發科), were famous for their skill at qínná. Shuāijiāo or Chinese jacket wrestling was popular among Manchu warrior caste members in Qing Dynasty China.

Yáng Chéngfǔ (楊澄甫) of Tàijíquán fame was a firearms instructor to the guard of King Duan and interacted with the palace wrestling corps during his tenure and is said to have extolled their skill.

Modern Shuāijiāo was codified in 1917 and taught in schools from 1928 — this is not accidental, given the popularity of jūdō in Japan at that time. Modern Shuāijiāo may have borrowed from or been influenced by jūdō at times, in terms of its rules and methods, as it was standardized.

There are several forms of traditional Chinese wrestling that differ in emphasis by geographical region. Shangxi wrestling is said to date from the Song Dynasty and Mongolian methods were practiced especially in the eastern regions. Beijing wrestling was heavily influenced by Manchu buku methods taught as part of the Manchu Imperial Guard Shàn Pū Yíng (善撲營) cadre during the Qing dynasty.

Totsuka-ha Yōshin-ryū was the jūjutsu style favored at the Kōbusho (講武所) academy of the Tokugawa. Some Jikishinkage-ryū masters cross-trained in Yōshin-ryū there and also learned spear methods related to Shinkage-ryū such as Hōzōin-ryū (宝蔵院流). By the late Edo there was already quite a bit of specialization in martial traditions, especially those associated with elite shogunate academies or domain schools.

Jikishinkage-ryū small sword or kodachi curriculum, introduces teachings about power and stability at close range that are useful armed or unarmed.

Classical traditions that place an emphasis on engaging an armed enemy or providing an armed response with small or auxiliary weapons or in batto, deploying a traditional katana, can develop their practitioners to the point where they are formidable at close range.

The rise of popularity of sportive grappling in jūdō and sportive aspects of kendō have had a mixed effect on classical grappling and weapons arts — first potentially improving them as mechanisms for repeated free practice and competitive matches were provided and later altering them to be optimized to those supervised encounters within the context of sport.

Just because an art has changed to emphasize sport, does not make it less effective in some way than its antecedents, especially if modern fitness methods or required training intensity improve the athletes far beyond levels of hobbyists who might have less time available for training.

However, with the de-prioritization of traditional kata practice, some of the mindset (e.g., zanshin) needed for armed combat can indeed be lost, as well as the opportunity for long periods of solo training needed for internal cultivation (be it concerned with physical power, mental resolve, sensitivity, balance, perception, intuition, or wisdom in varying amounts).

Approaches can be optimized to the point where they become nonsensical in a civilian self-defense scenario, let alone a military or paramilitary environment. As but one example, familiarity with weapons practices (deployment, application, retention, avoidance) become lost to the point where we see a very stylized use of the sword in Daitō-ryū and Aikidō.

It is important to recognize that Jikishinkage-ryū, while quite small in its number of practitioners, has at least already gone through its near total collapse. It has subsequently preserved a set of kata that are limited in number (five formal sets of teachings that contain possibly only thirty-three formal kata in total) and also is fortunate to be well-documented due to the efforts of past masters including Yamada Jirōkichi and others.

Attempting to record variations of teachings (sometimes called henka) as core teachings in an effort to have a larger curriculum that then must be maintained can disturb the learning process for principle-based martial arts. Maybe the vast number of kata of some arts are designed to stop people from learning the core principles of the art, if they were considered upper-level teachings, as opposed to being examples used to facilitate that process. Kata then became at times not only a teaching methodology but a means of social control as these groups grew in popularity and size, to help restrict their core to a smaller set of dedicated adherents.

Jikishinkage-ryū avoids that peril, but what to make of what remains is the subject of this book.

Free Practice

Stress testing in martial practice is important, whether it be through sparring within a group or in the rare circumstances where it is possible to engage in unscripted exchanges of hands between groups. The randomness of those encounters and the feedback they provide are very useful, and Jikishinkage-ryū embraced what is sometimes called jigeiko or tameshi-ai as a mechanism and crucible for self-discovery and refinement. In doing so, cultivating the proper mindset is crucial.

Arts have changed over time and modernization can very well be an improvement but preservation needs to be looked at carefully. Given the size of some traditional yawara curricula in the past, we need to remember they evolved largely during an extended period of peace during Edo Japan, enforced by a body politic consisting of strict military dictatorship. Novel combative insights in unscripted environments for many koryū may never have happened in the first place, depending on when their art was founded.

All kobudō and budō organizations today, as hobbies, fulfill primarily a social need for their practitioners. Most ryūha, even in the Edo period, were largely social organizations. They maintained formalized mock combative practices that preserved portions of combative knowledge inherited from the past. As the practice of dueling fell out of favor, these traditions were not truly tested as military application of Japanese martial traditions largely ended in 1615.

Duels happened during the Edo period, but were strictly regulated. In the 18^th^ and 19^th^ centuries, inter-school matches in grappling arts as well as gekken (撃剣) became more and more common. This led to the rise of both jūdō and kendō.

It is not as if the martial artists of that time period from 1600 to 1868 felt their arts too deadly to test against others. On the contrary, they were eager to do so and point systems, shinai and bogu enabled that process within the strictures of Tokugawa jurisprudence.

Then, in short, war. The Boshin war and the Meiji restoration tested samurai and commoners both. While much is written of the rise of Western approaches to formation, drill and weaponry (stylized in various movies), this conflict was led by factions all stemming from the samurai caste, dividing loyalty.

How does this relate to the modern practice of traditional martial arts? The contemporary sōke (宗家) and shihanke systems are genealogical or bureaucratic means, respectively, of establishing social order. The kata pattern system has then become a mechanism for maintaining social order once it is established. Most arts today, despite talk of license, are not set up to bring people through a training evolution and then send them on their way. Once you are in a group, you are generally in it for life — there is no social or economic advantage to graduating students.

In the past there are stories of the expense associated with graduation banquets and document preparation, where artisans such as calligraphers needed to be employed. Talented swordsmen could be limited in their advancement if they were bereft of sufficient income — there are also stories of teachers waiving such fees or covering the cost of documents for exceptional students.

Martial traditions are living entities. They evolve over time, can improve or decline based on the strength and interest of their practitioners. One must be careful when analyzing their merit and understand upon what assumptions that analysis is taking place.

Teachers can improve over time and it is okay for kata and waza to change over time as their understanding and skill increase, but we should not take teachers at their word when they describe what they are presenting as always being wholly unchanged from the past.

It is a weakness of a tradition if there are so many patterns of practice that senior teachers cannot keep track of them or rarely practice important portions of the full curriculum.

If a teacher has so many students he cannot teach in the traditional kata paradigm we are used to in older arts, and is teaching much more similarly to how arts like Aikidō, Jūdō and Daitō-ryū Aiki-jūjutsu are taught today, then regardless of the art’s genealogy, it has become a contemporary martial practice.

Free practice should be part of all martial traditions — the extent to which varies between lineage. This can take many forms, but solely kata focused practices that are conducted without stress testing are no longer being maintained as active martial traditions.

These factors are compounded when teaching in a modern seminar format, with only limited interaction with senior teachers who have full transmission of an art, and through their skill or reputation attract a very large number of students.

The shihanke and sōke social constructs are designed in part to ameliorate some of these hazards and functioned to do so during the Edo period despite most martial traditions disappearing over time.

Social structures can also introduce their own limitations, including a lack of free practice, increase of social or financial obligation and corruption of advancement based on factors other than through a display of skill at arms or proficiency at instruction. In that way, the most famous or central line of transmission of an art, or counter-intuitively the one that preserves the largest curriculum, may often not be the most robust.

Structure of This Work

Having set a stage hopefully of some small interest to a few readers, and shared one perspective on training, getting some strong opinions out of the way, we now turn to describing basic features of Jikishinkage-ryū practice including its characteristic methods of breathing, combative vocalization, posture, and its organization around Daoist five phase theory as applied to the calendar seasons.

We then analyze its kata curriculum, using recorded material from Waseda University: a mokuroku license issued in 1768, with red-ink notes beside most entries, and a densho copied in 1800 that glosses every kata. We contextualize technical material with the teaching poems (rika) preserved by Ishigaki and explain, as best we are able, how they might relate. Historical narrative is provided from contemporary Japanese sources where possible, including works that provide versions of or excerpts from Jikishinkage-ryū documents.

The mokuroku presents teaching aphorisms and guidelines for the first two sections of the school’s formal kata, along with lists of important methods of the school and a description of some of their key inner motivating principles called gokui. Our discussion of the document is interspersed with descriptions of key portions of each kata, their motivation, and possible applications of their teachings, especially in how they relate to other surviving lines of Shinkage-ryū, drawing from both personal experience and contemporary scholarship. Portions of practice are described and then explained, with a focus on combative applications encoded in the kata and their relationship first to historical writing available and second to internal martial arts principles.

We hope portions of the discussion are of interest, even if they may be idiosyncratic at times or contain errors of omission showing the limitations of the author’s understanding. Presented here is but one perspective, one we hope is intriguing to some who are interested in the genesis and evolution of older martial traditions, especially in their broader philosophical and cultural context.

There is ample film footage available of the standard kata practice of Jikishinkage-ryū as maintained by different related lineages that survive to this day, but little writing is available in English on the kata themselves and their broader organization and relationship. This work aims to fill that gap, informing those interested in classical and traditional sword methods, without attempting to be an instructional device.

One of the paradoxical things about contemporary budō culture versus how these arts were practiced in the Edo period, reading some recent scholarship, is that in the Edo period the Tokugawa were at times politically suspicious of the ryūha system. Many ryūha were organized around individual han, but others spanned across han. There was a sentiment that these societies were to be monitored and controlled so as to not be nexuses that could grow to threaten the shogunate. In order to show they were not keeping secrets, they started writing down their teachings in densho, examples of which survive to this day. Many densho were assumed to be read by outsiders at times, and were made non-threatening and also cryptic, to still contain material private to each ryū.5

I think that is why in the mid Edo period, with Naganuma Kunisato’s kudensho of 1764, we see the emphasis on Kashima Shinden in Jikishinkage-ryū introduced over earlier Mikkyō and Daoist concepts, as but one example. This points to the fact that kuden are very important in some arts, not just lists of gokui.

The quoted densho and much commentary, in the case of Jikishinkage-ryū, are publicly available both in publicly held source documents as well as published writings. We use those commentaries as points of departure to describe a portion of our own understanding of the art. This work is meant to be an analysis versus used for instruction. All errors are the author’s alone. Those seeking instruction should seek out more qualified sources. (Iwasa Masaru 2005; Ishigaki Yasuzō (石垣安造) 2001; Ogasawara Genshinsai (小笠原源信斎) 1670; Yoshida Katsunori (吉田克禮) 1768; Ogawa Yashichi (小川彌七) 1800; Yamada Jirōkichi (山田次朗吉) 1927)

Contents: The Truth of the Calm Spirit · Lineage → (opens in a new tab)

  1. The name Jikishinkage is alternately written as Jikishinkage, Jiki Shinkage, or Jikishin Kage, depending on the emphasis an author wishes to make. I standardize in this work on Jikishinkage, although my teacher favored Jiki Shinkage to emphasis it being a branch of Shinkage-ryū. ↩

  2. Roald Knutsen’s book Tengu (Knutsen 2011) provides a narrative of early migration of peoples’ to Japan, their interactions, and descriptions of both shamanistic and Daoist ascetic activities centered around sacred mountains and other remote features of nature. ↩

  3. Amdur, E., Hidden In Plain Sight (Amdur 2018) contains a detailed discussion of Chén and his influence. ↩

  4. Sawai Ken’ichi (澤井 健一; 1903–1988), who learned Yìquán in Manchuria, and Kohinata Hakurō (小日向白朗;1900 -1982) the “Little White Dragon”, being two notable exceptions. ↩

  5. cf. D. Pearson: https://shindomusoryu.org/into-the-old/ ↩