During this work, I utilized both historical records that had been annotated by advanced practitioners and are available publicly in libraries in Japan, as well as Japanese language books from the twentieth century.
Some of them, especially the work of Ishigaki (which has the word gokui in its title) detail many of the surviving writings of the art and describes aspects of its inner principles. Ishigaki inherited a family line of Jikishinkage-ryū that had stopped training some time after the second World War. He then wrote a book with their historical documents, poems, comments on gokui, etc., in an effort to assert the importance of his line of practice. So, the mention of gokui can be in the context of attempting to express dominance or priority in terms of matters of faction or succession.
People often have an instinctive idea that higher-level principles or gokui of specific surviving ryūha are private to each school. Their detailed explanations very well are, but historically these topics were listed in densho precisely so they could be at times inspected by the central authorities — in essence, to attest that the group was not teaching matters that were a potential threat to the Shogunate.
Kuden, or oral teachings, are explanations that go beyond the written gokui in some cases, unlocking necessary realizations needed to recreate or get as close as possible to the inspiration of the founders of these arts, especially when the foundational experience or its explication involve philosophical, religious, or abstract language inspired by vision, trance, or dream.
In the case of Jikishinkage-ryū, Yamada Jirokichi cataloged its teachings in an effort to preserve the tradition. Because the art had a number of practitioners of high social stature at the end of Tokugawa Shogunate, there was great interest in the art around the end of the nineteenth century as the art’s emphasis on shiai contributed in part to the development of modern kendo.
Gokui are organizing principles from one perspective should be teachings that inform and reinforce the training one is already undertaking, allowing it to be viewed more deeply than otherwise, and providing a window through which one can begin to see the art’s full realization or practice at its highest level of skill.
If one trains in kata properly, without explicit instruction in koto or gokui — say under a middle-level instructor — can one still obtain a very high level of skill? Or will, without the proper context, not only one’s practice be missing certain fundamental elements, but also constrained in how far the practice itself can be taken, even limiting analysis to what is explicitly contained in kata?
Paradoxically, modern swordsmen who have a strong practice of fundamentals and kata, are healthy and fit, and who engage in regular stress testing of their approach, might be better off combatively than others who have the full set of teachings of a system but do not train with intensity.
In writing this book, I became familiar with several concepts important to Jikishinkage-ryū practice that I had not been taught in the classes I attended, which focused heavily on the repetition of formal kata and then their comparison to other related arts, but not explicit instruction in the formal writings of Jikishinkage-ryū in and of itself.
In conducting this research, I realized over time how much ideas from Chinese martial arts were in Jikishinkage-ryū already in the 17th century. The idea people had that Ogasawara went to China for fifteen years and came back with one ‘gokui’ no one knew about or has seen since was false. Instead, I discovered strong overlap between some of the art’s central motivating principles and those of Chinese internal martial arts — in fact, some Daoist teachings common today to Tàijíquán and other arts are explicitly listed in the Jikishinkage-ryū mokuroku.
This is not surprising, given his travels. The research process helped me develop the courage to not keep my practice of kenjutsu isolated, like a museum piece, but rather to embed it in the larger framework of my internal martial arts practice.
Does being taught or even knowing what the gokui are, make one a better martial artist? Different, yes. Better, maybe. In one sense, you can’t say you practice an art if you don’t know its rationale. But even knowing gokui intellectually is not enough. You could still have a low level of practice if you don’t understand the essential teachings, come to the wrong conclusions, or do not have the proper foundations of practice being in place.
The gokui of Jikishinkage-ryū are at times very abstract, so I think they when taught likely have a lot of content and context to them, and I don’t think one can read a book and ‘get’ them. I put explanations to them in this book, but my gloss is just one interpretation. My writing in the chapter on gokui is mostly about philosophical and religious context, not explicit technique.
A person might learn gokui from more than one teacher. Did they learn marubashi before kōjō? The others? Are they taught in order? Do they stand independent of one another?
I make a claim that indeed the gokui are related to one another, and that they build upon and inform not only kata but the core tactics of the art, which precede the gokui in the historical mokuroku.
It is my belief that each gokui in Jikishinkage-ryū is a concrete teaching that changes a person’s perspective on the art. My having learned only kata, and not all the koto or gokui directly, is an important deficit in my training.
Marubashi is not listed among the gokui of the 1768 or 1800 mokuroku; like marobashi in other lines of Shinkage-ryū, it stands outside the written lists, and yet it serves as a capstone. In my training, we did spend much time considering that concept, as it relates closely to the concept of marobashi in Yagyū Shinkage-ryū, which my teacher also studied for many years (consulting with practitioners from several related lines of transmission). If the other gokui build up to marubashi, and we focused on that, and can utilize it in our swordsmanship, are we truly are at a loss?
This is the case of having an understanding some of the gokui, and trying to still practice an art completely or at least at a high level. There is another extreme — being given the gokui or kuden too early might actually damage one’s training and skill progression in an art. A student might have an idea of the ultimate purpose of the art, but might wind up not being as good as their contemporaries at the technical execution of the art, if they still do not receive enough direct instruction on the fine details of kata.
It is dangerous to ignore upper-level teaching but it also can be a challenge if one’s physical practice is lacking and one attempts to compensate too much with intellect. This may be what people referred to as the pitfall of the so-called ‘vacant’ schools of kenjutsu during the Edo period.
Just because someone tells you a kuden, it doesn’t magically fix everything or compensate for a lack of athleticism or regular training intensity with peers. If we are too isolated in our practice, we might wind up getting stuck and not know it. Also, by never doing shiai, our skill might not increase the way it would otherwise.
I believe people need to work together to keep these arts alive. In many cases, due to the sectarian nature of practice, and schisms within individual arts or groups, people are instead far too often unwilling to do so. Matters get compounded by training infrequently, at a distance, without close access to feedback and correction. Students living close to a strong dōjō will progress faster than otherwise, for a variety of reasons.
In the case of historical Jikishinkage-ryū mokuroku, we see a shift during the Edo period to downplay earlier esoteric Buddhist and Taoist influences over time. This happened in the mid-eighteenth century, under Naganuma Kunisato, when the lineage of the art was revised to place Matsumoto Bizen no Kami as its founder and the art renamed to include Kashima Shinden, divine inspiration from the Shintō deity Takemikazuchi (建御雷) as an important part of its identity.
My skill at Jikishinkage-ryū kata did not directly increase from conducting this exercise. Instead, I began thinking more deeply about what I did know.
In the case of gokui, I think more in terms of the concept of the essence of a thing or essential part of a thing, and not some secret or hidden concept or idea. Gokui to me are about connecting to the original or peak understanding of an art, versus an immediate teacher.
It is likely that interpretations of gokui shift over time, despite best efforts. Society, language, context can be very different now compared to five hundred years ago. A single word or phrase may be very hard to understand compared to in its original circumstance.
A 1978 budō studies paper by Okada Kazuo 岡田一男 of Kokugakuin University titled “Yagyū Shinkage-ryū Genryū-kō” (柳生新陰流源流考) in Budōgaku Kenkyū Vol. 10 No. 3, 1978, argued that the “three steps” (san no kazu) teaching of Yagyū Jūbei — where the logic of receiving and responding is the logic of ten (rolling or turning) — is fundamentally the same principle as Jikishinkage-ryū’s Marubashi.
Since aspects of the gokui are commented on in the literature we can at least go with what these swordsmen-authors describe. It makes things richer and more interesting, even not having explicitly learned all of the koto or gokui of Jikishinkage-ryū.
Some of the patterns cutting across kata could indeed be specific gokui — marobashi/marubashi is like this — so in some cases, if you properly understand the patterns underneath the kata, you will always be doing that art and will have the essence, whether you can describe it or not.
In some ways, gokui are the art, its essence, what the whole point of it is. Kata come in several flavors, ones that map directly to these essential matters, and also those that are designed to get someone to the point where they can understand the essential matters.
It is not a simple equation where you add the gokui and you are better. You need to know the gokui to even be doing the art at all. But it also may be the case that the many layers of kata developed over the years constituted a means of social control.
Better arts may paradoxically have less material in terms of kata because their principles are more directly or efficiently encoded in the pattern practice they maintain. Older kata might be more transparent rather than obscured. For example, the 108 shinai kata of Yagyū Shinkage-ryū are a preparatory and explanatory set, and important to Yagyū pedagogy, but one can have a robust practice only practicing the older historical sets of kata. Kamiizumi Ise no Kami certainly did not need them to obtain his own realizations. It is a bit counter-intuitive, as one might expect having more forms means you are better in some way or know more about kenjutsu. Originally, many kata were likely short because they directly encoded a few distinguishing ideas. But people sometimes embellish, obscure, or rearrange things from generation to generation.
By paring down kata, and looking for patterns across them, we are essentially making our own gokui. Those might even match closely the actual historical gokui of an art — this is hard to know for certain. It is important to go back to sources to see if your understanding is correct. In principle better means you will be a better swordsman if your operating system matches more closely masters like Kamiizumi. How to know this outside the realm of vision, trance or dream mentioned above, is unclear.
If Gokui are essential principles, kuden may be explanations that help unlock the kata and gokui. They are different than the gokui, the driving principles of the art.
One example from an art I once studied. In Shintō-ryū there are no blocks. There are only cuts. You will hear people say, “every cut is a lie”. So you look at the kata and every time the swords clack, you know something else is supposed to happen. Katori Shintō-ryū is encoded that way. There is a danger that if you never take the time to decode the kata, and practice it in a different way than it is first encoded, you will never actually get to the point you are supposed to arrive at. The gokui shichijo no kata you learn later on in the art’s progression more explicitly encodes this structure (the blades almost never clash), so maybe once you learn the shichijo, you would then go back and practice all of the previous kata that way. Most people don’t. They too often get fixated on how quick the shichijo kata are, and try to mimic that light feeling everywhere — that might be a mistake.1
I think even when someone receives an upper-level license in a specific approach, it doesn’t mean they necessarily know all the gokui well. It may simply mean the teacher is finished teaching them. They may have imparted all of their knowledge, or what they consider to be ‘enough’ for the student to go the rest of the way.
It might be necessary for high-level practitioners of arts to continue to do their own research. Or, conversely, maybe one reason we at times see people who have high-level ranks on paper not being great is they only take their training to a certain point, and don’t look past what they were shown. Maybe the worst thing that can happen to you is being told you are a master.
Still, some brave souls continue to refine their practice and work very hard at it, even many decades into their practice.
However, that means their art changes over time. Ideally, their efforts will comport with the principles they learned, and they are mindful when adding new principles. Being too radical in an evolution runs the risk that students — if you have begun teaching — will not be able to follow you.
People who train as the teacher’s practice is converging on what their ultimate expression is – so that things are changing less rapidly – might have an advantage in some way over earlier students. There might be a disruptive period when you are shifting to a different body organization from what you were first taught, or a different mental model for your practice. Some people may be unwilling or unable to follow you. That is their loss — not all students can follow their teachers on their journey.
Gokui are important because if they are respected, the changes being made by an advanced practitioner are still within the construct of the same approach. If you change the gokui too much, you have invented a new style, which in today’s world, will never be fully tested. In my case, studying writings about the gokui of Jikishinkage-ryū has changed my perspective on kenjutsu. Early Jikishinkage-ryū was once much closer to the principles I have since learned from Chinese internal martial arts.
There are other gokui that are written as obscure philosophical concepts. Seikōsui (西江水; the water of the West River) was for a long time one example: what swallowing a river has to do with swordsmanship was unclear to me. The densho answer it. The 1768 red ink reads it as “drink the western sea dry”, the depth and breadth of training; the 1800 densho says that it means casting off the full body and settling it into the kikai tanden (氣海丹田; the sea of ki below the navel). That brings it close to the idea in Tàijíquán of “swallowing” someone’s force by sinking it, and it may relate back to advanced approaches to go-no-sen in Jikishinkage-ryū.
We end, like they may also: at the beginning.
There is more work to be done in analyzing these traditions and relating them to one another. As technology continues to improve and translations of older documents in cursive script become more readily available to non-Japanese researchers of these arts, we are hopeful more progress can be made in relating their origins and practices to one another in more of a coherent and cohesive picture of the early formalisations of medieval grappling and weapons arts from Japan, especially restoring narrative about Chinese influences on these arts, after a long period of Japan sine qua non as only Japanese, Yamato-damashii (大和魂), and the participation of Zen teachers and organizations in ultra-nationalism influencing the official literature.
In the case of Jikishinkage-ryū kenjutsu, when viewed as a whole, including the material from its upper-level writings and increasingly austere physical practices, we find what can best be described as an art that utilizes a mixture of internal and external principles drawn from both Daoism and Buddhism (both Zen and Mikkyō) to forge a unified approach to kenjutsu that is outwardly constrained and refined, but conceals in the shadows of its practice a great depth that can be explored over a lifetime.
In this work, I hope to have provided a small window into that experience.
All practice begins and ends with rei (禮; etiquette) and Hōjō is an extreme form of just that, in both its outward (manifest) and hidden variations. Regardless of all that has been written above, what we can say for certain is that the four seasons and the rise and fall of yin and yang will continue, long after we are all gone.
The Hōjōken kokoro-e sho (法定劔心得書; Text on Understanding Foundational Swordsmanship) is a creed concerned with Hōjō practice that is chanted or recited before performance of the kata in certain lines of practice. Apart from the one clause quoted in discussing the reiken, we do not reproduce it here, but simply echo its sentiment.
This practice, described in detail above, is not simply combative. It is something far more profound that unites heaven and earth, manifesting the divine. It is this universal aspect we seek to attain when we view Shinkage-ryū as a method of self-cultivation. Doing so, we strive to return to a pure, direct, clear, and calm heart and mind.
A final thought and an admonition.
This research has led me to be very cautious about the limits of my current understanding. I believe on the whole I have improved my practice of kenjutsu by embracing internal martial arts principles. This I feel is quite compatible with Jikishinkage-ryū, but makes my practice unorthodox. I am grateful for the instruction I received and for the patience that was shown to me as I first struggled to train in multiple approaches.
The phrase hyakuren jitoku (百錬自得) means that through a great deal of practice you can better understand yourself. Part of me feels it is important now that I have coalesced into a single mindset, to keep wandering up the mountain path of shugyō, even if I struggle at times as I do so. I hope this research will be of some small value to others on their own journeys. I am reminded that the final level of practice of Jikishinkage-ryū is silent. It is time for me to embrace that silence as a path.
Contents: The Truth of the Calm Spirit · ← Older Kata (opens in a new tab)
-
The shichijo are seven “essential articles” and while they are presented as three kata each expressing a different initiative (sente), they are supposed to teach seven gokui. These are named in academic scholarship on Shintō-ryū. ↩
